Working Paper Series
2026
Exclusive Contracts in the Video Streaming Market
Yihao Yuan
I study who gains and who loses from exclusive contracts in the video streaming market, where studios grant streaming services exclusive rights to distribute their content. Streaming services can use these contracts to differentiate their content offerings and soften competition, while studios may leverage them to negotiate higher license fees from streaming services. I develop and estimate a structural model that incorporates bargaining between streaming services and studios, streaming services setting subscription prices, and consumer demand for subscriptions and titles. I find that streaming services that lack in-house content (like Hulu) gain from exclusive contracts, while those with extensive in-house content (like Netflix) see minimal or even negative effects. For studios, exclusive contracts benefit small studios with weak bargaining power but harm large ones with strong bargaining power. While exclusive contracts harm consumers due to reduced title distribution and higher subscription prices, they may benefit consumers in the long run by stimulating content production and streaming service entry.
Survey-Shield: Testing and Strengthening Data Quality Safeguards Against Agentic Threats to Online Surveys
Craig Fox, Andrea Low, Kianté Fernandez, Jon Bogard
Online surveys are central to marketing and data analytics research, yet AI agents can now complete surveys while evading many standard bot-detection safeguards. This project develops and validates Survey-Shield (survey-shield.com), a publicly available tool that reviews a survey instrument against a set of bot-resistance categories and returns a standardized quality score. We pair this with an audit of survey instruments published in the Journal of Consumer Research, applying Survey-Shield to estimate how vulnerable published studies would be to AI-agent completion. The project offers researchers a framework for standardized reporting of survey data quality and actionable guidance for strengthening their surveys.
Affiliate Marketing: Competition Patterns and Disclosure Gaps
Brett Hollenbeck, Charlotte Zhu
The Household Benefits of Generative AI: Evidence from Internet Browsing Data
Gregor Schubert, Michael Blank, Miao Ben Zhang
This paper studies the impact of generative AI on U.S. households' task allocation at home, using detailed Internet browsing data from a large sample of home devices between 2021 and 2024. Leveraging pre-ChatGPT browsing patterns, we measure households' exposure to ChatGPT and use it as an instrument for ChatGPT adoption during the post-release period. Our IV estimates show that adopting generative AI substantially increases leisure browsing on home devices while leaving time spent on productive digital tasks unchanged. To examine mechanisms, we infer the purpose of households' ChatGPT use from surrounding internet activity and find that households primarily employ it for productive non-market tasks. Together, these results suggest that generative AI frees up leisure time by raising the efficiency of productive digital activities. Interpreting these findings through a standard time-allocation model implies economically large productivity gains from generative AI at home.
Working Paper
Widely-Used Measures of Overconfidence Are Confounded With Ability
Stephen Spiller
Measures of overconfidence are used both to assess biases in people’s beliefs regarding their own abilities and to identify correlates of those biases. Proposed correlates of overconfidence include narcissism, social status, (low) task anxiety, savings, planning, and many more. Research on these correlates typically explicitly or implicitly claims the associations with overconfidence are not attributable to ability (i.e., latent inputs enabling successful task performance, including inputs that vary across people, states, or contexts). I argue that several typical approaches used to measure overconfidence are not sufficient to support such claims. This argument follows from two underappreciated properties of these measures of overconfidence. First, performance is an imperfect measure of ability: accounting for performance does not sufficiently account for ability. Second, self-evaluations of performance should reflect ability in addition to performance: because performance is ambiguous, people should incorporate prior beliefs about their ability. These properties imply multiple commonly-used measures of overconfidence are confounded with ability. I support these analytical results by reexamining previously-published findings. In the first analysis, I find overconfidence predicts subsequent performance, consistent with measures of overconfidence serving as a signal of ability. In the second set of analyses, I find some purported associations between overconfidence and other constructs could be attributed to ability instead. I close with recommendations to recognize and reduce the potential for mistaken inferences. When research indicates that differences in overconfidence are associated with other behaviors, beliefs, or evaluations, researchers should account for the possibility that differences in ability could provide a sufficient explanation.
The Power of Words: How Role Model Messages Shape Workplace Self-Advocacy
Sherry Wu, Aurelia Di
When Hobbies Become an Obligation: Generational Differences in Sources of Time Poverty
Cassie Mogilner Holmes, Mercy Luo, Maria Trupia
Pricing Insurance, Fairly
Eitan Rude, Franklin Shaddy, Hal Hershfield
Insurance is one of the oldest and most ubiquitous financial products, and numerous industries rely on healthy insurance markets to function. Actuarially, insurance premiums largely depend on the likelihood of making claims (“risk levels”) and the size of potential claims (“coverage needs”). Consequently, when risk levels and coverage needs increase — e.g., when the frequency and severity of natural disasters increase due to climate change — so too should premiums. Yet consumers typically believe it is unfair for insurers to increase premiums, triggering a host of market distortions (and even market failure). How, then, do consumers believe insurance should be priced? Across 10 preregistered experiments (N = 6,379), we show that consumers view it as less fair for insurers to increase premiums when risk levels increase than when coverage needs increase, holding expected value constant. Additionally, we explore the implications of this distinction for purchase intentions, the acceptability of price discrimination, and support for insurance mandates. Finally, we propose a novel mechanism to explain these beliefs: risk levels may feel less personally controllable than coverage needs. As such, our work not only sheds new light on the psychology of insurance but also offers new insights into the antecedents of price fairness.
Paper
Framing Costs and Benefits of Public Policies in Conjoint Measurement of Voter Preferences
Robert Zeithammer, James Macinko
Retirement Attitudes: What People Think About When They Think About Retirement
Hal Hershfield, Andrea Low, Eitan Rude
Many people can now expect to spend well over a decade in retirement. This project examines what people think about when they consider retirement, and what predicts differences in how they think about it. In this research, participants in the United States, United Kingdom, and Japan complete an open-ended conversation with an AI chatbot about their retirement expectations, followed by a survey. We identify and examine recurring themes such as excitement, priorities, and worries, that surface from what people raise when they discuss retirement. We test which themes are most prevalent, and whether the themes people raise vary with savings, age, gender, and country. The findings will inform how financial services firms design retirement products and messaging across markets and audiences.
Temporal Planning for Retirement
Cassie Mogilner Holmes, Hal Hershfield, Mercy Luo
How People Predict Others' Preferences from Incomplete Choice Sets
Mercy Luo, Stephen Spiller
Why Explicit Time Reminders Increase On-Time Arrival
Andrea Low, Alicea Lieberman, Stephen Spiller
Consumers Infer Stronger Preference from Willingness to Pay than from Equivalent Willingness to Accept
Franklin Shaddy, Maria Trupia
Prices or Quantities? How Policy Goals Shape Preferences for Regulatory Tools
Arianna Chiappi, Eitan Rude, Franklin Shaddy
Consumer Preferences for Data Sharing: The Role of Temporal Orientation
Mercy Luo, Franklin Shaddy
How Market Signals About Supply and Demand Shape Valuation
Qingyang Wang, Franklin Shaddy
How Consumers Anticipate and Experience Wasted Time
Shelly Tsang, Cassie Mogilner Holmes
Consumer Trust Is Determined by What Is Missing, Not What Is Disclosed
Stephen Spiller, Qingyang Wang
Should I Disclose AI Use? Miscalibration Between Managers and Employees in Performance Feedback
Chelsea Tianyi Che, Aurelia Aochun Di, Hengchen Dai
Framing the Future: Sector-Specific and Intertemporal Messaging to Increase Pro-Environmental Action
Shelli Orzach, Hal Hershfield
The User Experiences of AI Consultation: Psychological Needs and Consequences for Well-Being and Performance
Sherry Wu, Hengchen Dai, Hanqiu Li
Individual Differences In Thinking of Time as a Resource
Shelly Tsang, Hal Hershfield
Consumer Knowledge of Brand Portfolios and Boycott Spillovers
Christopher Poliquin, Richard Li, Young Hou
How Planning Shapes Social Connection
Alicea Lieberman, Cassie Mogilner Holmes, Shelly Tsang
Platform Integration, Developer Entry, and Commission Policy in App Markets
Brett Hollenbeck, Charlotte Zhu
What Goes Unsaid: From Consumer Preferences to AI Recommendations
Bolun Xiao, H. Tai Lam
From Moral Beauty to Moral Scrutiny: How Moral Transgressions Shape Consumer Responses to Purpose-Driven Brands
Sanjay Sood, Neha Nair
Mapping the Bounds of Religious Authority in the Marketplace: Consumer Responses to Religious Endorsement Across Product Domains
Sanjay Sood, Neha Nair
Before or After Professional Commitment? Consequences of Minority Identity Disclosure for Professionals
Joyce He, Hyunjin Cha, Katherine Sun
Advancing LLM-Detection and Prevention Methods for Market Research
Brett Hollenbeck, Stephen Spiller
2025
Life Shocks and Future Self Connectedness
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-001
Hal Hershfield and Eitan Rude
Kindness to the Future vs. Current Self
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-002
Hal Hershfield, Naomi Eisenberger, and Maria Naclerio,
Affiliate Marketing: Competition Patterns and Disclosure Gaps
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-003
Brett Hollenbeck and Charlotte Zhu
Pricing Insurance, Fairly
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-004
Franklin Shaddy, Eitan Rude, and Hal Hershfield,
Insurance is one of the oldest and most ubiquitous financial products, and numerous industries rely on healthy insurance markets to function. Actuarially, insurance premiums largely depend on the likelihood of making claims (“risk levels”) and the size of potential claims (“coverage needs”). Consequently, when risk levels and coverage needs increase — e.g., when the frequency and severity of natural disasters increase due to climate change — so too should premiums. Yet consumers typically believe it is unfair for insurers to increase premiums, triggering a host of market distortions (and even market failure). How, then, do consumers believe insurance should be priced? Across 10 preregistered experiments (N = 6,379), we show that consumers view it as less fair for insurers to increase premiums when risk levels increase than when coverage needs increase, holding expected value constant. Additionally, we explore the implications of this distinction for purchase intentions, the acceptability of price discrimination, and support for insurance mandates. Finally, we propose a novel mechanism to explain these beliefs: risk levels may feel less personally controllable than coverage needs. As such, our work not only sheds new light on the psychology of insurance but also offers new insights into the antecedents of price fairness.
The Welfare Impact of Ad-Supported Plans in the Video Streaming Market
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-005
Yihao Yuan, Sylvia Hristakeva, Julie Holland Mortimer, and Ashwin Nair
Consumer Preferences for Saving- vs. Spending-Oriented Financial Strategies
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-006
Hal Hershfield, Mercy Luo, and Abigail Sussman
Covariation Bias
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-007
Stephen Spiller and Andrea Low
This project investigates covariation bias—a systematic tendency for people to perceive associations between variables as more positive than they truly are. We find that individuals consistently overestimate positive relationships in visual and numerical data, even when no true correlation exists. This research aims to identify why this bias occurs, test its boundary conditions, and explore how it affects confidence and decision-making. Understanding covariation bias has direct implications for marketing and data analytics, where managers and consumers alike rely on pattern recognition to draw conclusions from complex data. By documenting how people misread correlations, this work can inform better visualization design, improve interpretation of marketing metrics, and reduce errors in forecasting and performance evaluation. Ultimately, the project advances behavioral science theory while providing actionable insights for data-driven organizations.
Studying Effective Listening in Conversation Using Callbacks
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-008
Hanne Collins and Yaoxi Shi
The Household Benefits of Generative AI: Evidence from Internet Browsing Data
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-009
Gregor Schubert, Michael Blank, and Miao Ben Zhang
This paper studies the impact of generative AI on U.S. households' task allocation at home, using detailed Internet browsing data from a large sample of home devices between 2021 and 2024. Leveraging pre-ChatGPT browsing patterns, we measure households' exposure to ChatGPT and use it as an instrument for ChatGPT adoption during the post-release period. Our IV estimates show that adopting generative AI substantially increases leisure browsing on home devices while leaving time spent on productive digital tasks unchanged. To examine mechanisms, we infer the purpose of households' ChatGPT use from surrounding internet activity and find that households primarily employ it for productive non-market tasks. Together, these results suggest that generative AI frees up leisure time by raising the efficiency of productive digital activities. Interpreting these findings through a standard time-allocation model implies economically large productivity gains from generative AI at home.
Effects of Smartphones on Creativity
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-010
Alicea Lieberman, Cassie Mogilner Holmes, and Megan Weber,
How people make evaluations of what is a waste of time
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-011
Cassie Mogilner Holmes and Shelly Tsang
Understanding How Choice Set Origin Shapes Predictions of Others’ Preferences
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-012
Stephen Spiller and Mercy Luo
Fake Reviews and Consumer Welfare
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-013
Brett Hollenbeck and Ashvin Gandhi
Who Deserves More? Navigating Need vs. Merit in Crowdfunding Decisions
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-014
Stephen Spiller and Qingyang Wang
Scarcity Cues vs. Social Proof: How Supply and Demand Shocks Shape Valuation
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-015
Franklin Shaddy and Qingyang Wang
Testing and Strengthening Data Quality Safeguards
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-016
Craig Fox, Andrea Low, Kiante Fernandez, and Jon Bogard
Advances in automation and generative AI have created new challenges for data integrity in online behavioral and marketing research. This project develops and validates SurveyShield, a tool designed to evaluate and strengthen the quality of survey data. Using automated agents and large language models to simulate modern threats such as bots and duplicate participation, we systematically test which common quality checks remain effective and identify areas where traditional safeguards break down. The resulting platform will provide researchers and practitioners with standardized quality scores and implementation guides, helping ensure that research responses come from real, unique human participants. By making these resources publicly available, the project aims to enhance transparency, replicability, and confidence in data across both academic research and applied data analytics.
Understanding Consumer Responses to Purpose-Driven Brands: The Role of Moral Identity Centrality
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-017
Sanjay Sood and Neah Nair
From Sacred to Discarded: Consumer Perceptions of Religious Object Disposal
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-018
Sanjay Sood and Neah Nair
Review on the Concept of Intervention Intensity in Financial Behavior Intervention
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 25-019
Hal Hershfield, Andres Low, Nadyanna Majeed, and Andree Hartanto
2024
Selling Pseudo-Science: Is More Regulation Needed?
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-001
Elizabeth Honka, Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Rui A, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
How Digital Detoxes Impact Productivity, Academic Outcomes, and Social Connection
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-002
Cassie Mogilner, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Alicea Lieberman, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Megan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Individual Attitudes and Behaviors Towards Bureaucracy
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-003
Stephen Spiller, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Associate Dean of Anderson Ph.D. Program
Andrea Low, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Price Optimization and Waste Reduction In Secondary Food Markets
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-004
Auyon Siddiq, Assistant Professor of Decisions, Operations and Technology Management, UCLA Anderson
When Does Comparative Feedback Backfire?
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-005
Craig Fox, Harold Williams Chair and Professor of Management, Area Chair, UCLA Anderson
Craig Brimhall, Postdoctoral Scholar in Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Understanding Consumer Preferences for Homeowners insurance
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-006
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Eitan Rude, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
How do Extreme Violation and Non-Violations Affect Perceptions?
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-007
Margaret Shih, Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Elizabeth Jiang, M & O Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Fairness Perceptions in Demographic Targeting
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-008
Olivier Toubia, Glaubinger Professor of Business at Columbia Business School
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Elizabeth Friedman, Assistant Professor of Business Columbia Business School
The Rent is Too Damn High! Preferences for Supply- vs. Deman-Oriented Policy Solutions to Scarcity
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-009
Ryan Hamilton, Director at School of Theater, Film & Television, UCLA
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Linda Hagen, Assistant Professor of Marketing, University of Illinois Chicago
Do Discount Rates Vary with Respect to Climate Outcomes
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-010
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Shelli Orzarch, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Harnessing Generative AI for Engaging and Scalable Behavioral Interventions
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-011
Hengchen Dai, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Hanqiu Li, M&O Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Exploring AI’s Influence on Attitude Change: A Data-Driven Analysis of Social Matters
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-012
Jennifer Whitson, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Hanqiu Li, M&O Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Disclosure and Innovation
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-013
Jennifer Kao, Assistant Professor of Strategy, UCLA Anderson
Colleen Cunningham, Professor and Chair — Department of Pediatrics, UCI School of Medicine
Understanding the Role of Bottom-Up Visual Salience on Consumer Decisions
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-014
Keith Chen, Professor of Behavioral Economics, UCLA Anderson
Kate Feinerman, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Alice Liu Yang, Endowed Term Chair in Teaching Excellence, UCLA Anderson
What’s Meant vs. Heard When Communication Busyness
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-015
Cassie Mogilner, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Maria Trupia, Postdoctoral Scholar in the Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Consumers Believe Revenues Affect Profits More than Equilavent Expenses
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-016
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Maria Trupia, Postdoctoral Scholar in the Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Citizen Myopia
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-017
Craig Fox, Harold Williams Chair and Professor of Management, UCLA Anderson
Megan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Impact of Brand Purpose on Consumer Well-Being: Role of Consumer Purpose and Moral Elevation Experience
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-018
Sanjay Sood, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Neha Nair, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Assembly or Components? Understanding Judgments of Product Origin
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-019
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Qingyang Wang, Ph.D. student in the Department of Statistics at UCLA
Preference Matching or Sacrificing? Self-Preference Variations in Joint Consumption
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-020
Stephen Spiller, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Qingyang Wang, Ph.D. student in the Department of Statistics at UCLA
Tradeoffs Between Policies and Consequences in Health Insurance Policy Preferences: Medicare Option vs. Taxes
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-021
Robert Zeithammer, Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Raphael Thomadsen, Professor of Marketing, Olin Business School - Washington University
Honesty First: How Pre-Task Pledges Reduce Dishonest Behavior
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-022
Eugene Caruso, Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Sam Skowronek, Postdoctoral Scholar in the Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Closing the Benefits-Participation Gap by Understanding the Psychology of Recipient Empowerment and Devaluation
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-023
Eugene Caruso, Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Heather Caruso, Associate Dean, Equity, Diversity and Inclusion, UCLA Anderson
Llana Brody, PhD Candidate in Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Samantha Kassirer, Postdoctoral Research Scholar at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management in the Marketing and OBHRM departments
Sherry Wu, Assistant Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Forecasting Future Obstacles and Demand for Commitment Devices
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-024
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Megan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
The Impact of Large Language Models on Consumer Product Search and Advertising
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 24-025
Tai Lam, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
2023
Reminding People of the Ephemerality of Behaviors Increases Goal Completion
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-001
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonAlicea Lieberman, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Fake Reviews and Consumer Welfare
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-002
Brett Hollenbeck, Associate Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonAshvin Gandhi, Assistant Professor, UCLA Anderson
utation systems by sellers on two-sided online platforms. We focus on a relevant empirical
setting, the use of fake product reviews on e-commerce platforms, which can affect consumer
welfare via two channels. First, rating manipulation deceives consumers directly, causing
them to buy lower quality products and pay higher prices for the products with manipulated
ratings. Second, the presence of rating manipulation lowers trust in ratings, which may
result in worse product matches if consumers place too little weight on quality ratings. This
decrease in trust may also increase price competition and benefit consumers by lowering
prices on high quality products whose quality is less easily observed. We formally model
how consumers form beliefs about quality from product ratings and how these beliefs are
affected by the presence of fake reviews. This model of product quality is incorporated into
an empirical model of consumer demand for products and how demand is shifted by ratings,
reviews, and prices. The model is estimated using a large and novel dataset of products
observed buying fake reviews to manipulate their Amazon ratings. We use counterfactual
policy simulations in which fake reviews are removed and consumer beliefs adjust accord-
ingly to explore the effectiveness and welfare and profit implications of different methods of
regulating fake reviews.
The Impact of Legalized Sports Gambling on Consumer Debt
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-003
Brett Hollenbeck, Associate Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonDavid Proserpio, Assistant Professor of Marketing, USC Marshall School of Business
Budgeting Increases Reliance on Category-Level Evaluations
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-004
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Associate Dean of Anderson Ph.D. Program, UCLA Anderson
David Dolifka, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
People Endorse Harsher Policies in Principle Than in Practice: Asymmetric Beliefs About Which Errors to Prevent Versus Fix
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-005
Society for Judgment and Decision Making’s Hillel Einhorn New Investigator Award 2023
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Eitan Rude, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Countless policies are crafted with the intention of punishing all who do wrong or rewarding only those who do right. However, this requires accommodating certain mistakes: some who do not deserve to be punished might be, and some who deserve to be rewarded might not be. Six preregistered experiments (N = 3,484 U.S. adults) reveal that people are more willing to accept this trade-off in principle, before errors occur, than in practice, after errors occur. The result is an asymmetry such that for punishments, people believe it is more important to prevent false negatives (e.g., criminals escaping justice) than to fix them, and more important to fix false positives (e.g., wrongful convictions) than to prevent them. For rewards, people believe it is more important to prevent false positives (e.g., welfare fraud) than to fix them, and more important to fix false negatives (e.g., improperly denied benefits) than to prevent them.
The Role that Evidence Plays in Dishonest Reporting
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-006
Eugene Caruso, Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral, UCLA AndersonSam Skowronek, Ph.D. in Operations, Information, and Decisions, The Wharton School
Evaluating Point and Range Predictions Under Epistemic vs. Aleatory Uncertainty
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-007
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonCraig Fox, Harold Williams Chair and Professor of Management, Area Chair, UCLA Anderson
Eitan Rude, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Using data analytics to identify gender differences in postnatal labor market attachment
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-008
Jana Gallus, Associate Professor of Strategy and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonJennifer Kao, Assistant Professor of Strategy, UCLA Anderson
Female Medical Students are Less Likely to Submit a Truthful Rank Ordering of Preferences in the National Residency Match Program
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-009
Joyce He, Assistant Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonSam Skowronek, Ph.D. in Operations, Information, and Decisions, The Wharton School
The Politics of Minority Portrayal
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-010
Margaret Shih, Department Chair and Deputy Dean of Academic Affairs, Neil Jacoby Chair in Management; Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonElizabeth Jiang, M & O Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
“No Time to Buy”: Asking Consumers to Spend Time to Save Money is Perceived as Fairer than Asking Consumers to Spend Money to Save Time
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-011
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonMaria Trupia, Postdoctoral Scholar, UCLA Anderson
Committing to Outcomes vs. Actions
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-012
Alicea Lieberman, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonMegan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Citizen Myopia
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-013
Craig Fox, Harold Williams Chair and Professor of Management, Area Chair, UCLA AndersonMegan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
The Role of Stock-Flow Reasoning in Understanding the Social Security Trust Fund
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-014
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Associate Dean of Anderson Ph.D. Program, UCLA Anderson
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA Anderson
Megan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Suzanne Shu, Professor Emeritus, UCLA Anderson
New Money or More of the Same? Tracking the Meaning of Financial Growth
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-015
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Associate Dean of Anderson Ph.D. Program, UCLA AndersonDavid Dolifka, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Qingyang Wang, Ph.D Marketing Student, UCLA Anderson
Bidding by heterogeneously risk-averse bidders in first-price auctions with reserves
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-016
Robert Zeithammer, Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonLucas Stich, Assistant Professor, Wurzburg University
Double marginalization in digital advertising markets run by auctions
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-017
Robert Zeithammer, Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonW. Jason Choi, Assistant Professor, Robert H. Smith School of Business, University of Maryland
Brand Imagery and Ethnic Cue (Mis)Matches
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-018
Sanjay Sood, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonNeha Nair, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Karl Aquino, Richard Poon Professor of Organizations and Society at the UBC Sauder School of Business, Marketing and Behavioural Science Division
Do Discount Rates Vary with Respect to Climate Outcomes
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-019
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonShelli Orzach, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Pluralistic Ignorance of Stigma Impedes Take-Up of Welfare Benefits
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-020
Eugene Caruso, Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral, UCLA AndersonSherry Wu, Assistant Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Alice Lee-Yon, PhD Candidate in Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Unraveling the Role of Market Concentration in the Price Puzzle
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-021
Shohini Kundu, Assistant Professor of Finance, UCLA AndersonJinyuan Zhang, Assistant Professor of Finance, UCLA Anderson
Antitrust in Advertising-Subsidized Markets: Youtube Content Economy
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-023
Tai Lam, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonUnderstanding Time Poverty for Consumer Research
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-024
Cassie Mogilner, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Bud Knapp Marketing Professorship, UCLA AndersonMaria Trupia, Postdoctoral Scholar, UCLA Anderson
Vividness of the future and demand for commitment
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 23-025
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonMegan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
2022
The Intersection of Political Beliefs and Diversity Representation: Understanding Responses to Stereotype Content in Ads
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-001
Margaret Shih, Department Chair and Deputy Dean of Academic Affairs, Neil Jacoby Chair in Management; Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonElizabeth Jiang, M & O Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Framings of Uncertainty and Intentions to Take Protective Action
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-002
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonEitan Rude, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Investigating The Role of Binary versus Continuous Framing on Cheating and Punishment
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-003
Euguene Caruso, Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, Bing (’86) and Alice Liu Yang Endowed Term Chair in Teaching Excellence, Faculty Co-Director, Inclusive Ethics Initiative, UCLA AndersonDaniel Mirny, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
The Effect of Price Caps on Pharmaceutical Advertising: Evidence from the 340b Drug Pricing Program
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-004
Sylvia Hristakeva, Assistant Professor, Cornell SC Johnson College of BusinessJulie Holland Mortimer, Full Professor, Boston College
The Fox News Effect on Attitudes Towards The Scope of Policing
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-005
Kareem Haggag, Assistant Professor of Behavioral Economics, UCLA AndersonEric Chyn, Assistant Professor, Dartmouth College
Bocar Abdoulaye Ba, Assistant Professor, Duke University
Leveraging Past Adversity to Increase Academic Success
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-006
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonIlana Brody, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
A Behavioral Study of Self-other Adoption Discrepancies in Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI)
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-007
Fernanda Bravo, Assistant Professor of Decisions, Operations and Technology Management, UCLA AndersonZezhen (Dawn) He, PhD in Operations Management, Simon School of Business, University of Rochester
Yaron Shaposhnik, Assistant Professor of Information Systems and Operations Management, Simon School of Business, University of Rochester
León Valdés, Assistant Professor of Business Administration, University of Pittsburgh
Online Quality Scores, Competition and Welfare
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-008
Brett Hollenbeck, Associate Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonDavide Proserpio, Assistant Professor of Marketing at the USC Marshall School of Business
Consumers Believe Legal Products Are Less Effective Than Illegal Products
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-009
Alicia Lieberman, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonSydney Scott, Assistant Professor of Marketing, Olin Business School
Rachel Gershon, Assistant Professor of Marketing, Haas Business School, UC Berkeley
Doing Good by Doing Business: Brand Purpose and Its Impact on Consumers
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-010
Sanjay Sood, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonNeha Nair, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Human vs Robots: Tipping for Services
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-011
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonDavid Dolifka, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Neha Nair, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Present Benefit Precommitments to Encourage Prosocial Action
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-012
Craig Fox, Harold Williams Chair and Professor of Management, Area Chair, UCLA AndersonMegan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Investment Decision Making and Fear of Missing Out
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-013
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonMegan Weber, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
From Warm Glow to Cold Chill: Choice Avoidance in Charitable Donations
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-014
Awarded “Best Paper” at the 84th Annual Meeting of the Academy of Management (AOM 2024)
Hengchen Dai, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Jana Gallus, Associate Professor of Strategy and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Ilana Brody, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
As charitable organizations increasingly introduce choice into donation opportunities, they may be overlooking a critical psychological construct inherent in framing a choice between multiple deserving populations. We propose that a donation choice framed as a choice between “who to help” elicits concerns about fairness and decision burdens, which ultimately reduces donations relative to the same donation opportunity framed as a choice between “what to give”. This research will advance our understanding of the impact of choice and framing on judgment and decision making in the consequential context of charitable giving. The research will also offer solutions to help charities increase donations.
When Impact Appeals Backfire: Evidence from a Multinational Field Experiment and the Lab
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-015
Hengchen Dai, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonJana Gallus, Associate Professor of Strategy and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Joseph Reiff, Assistant Professor of Marketing, University of Maryland
Firms often try to motivate customers to share feedback by telling customers that their feedback will have an impact on the organization (e.g., “Have your say in our company’s direction”). We examine whether such “impact appeals” indeed increase compliance with customer feedback requests. In a field experiment across seven countries, 430,666 customers of a Fortune 500 company received a customer feedback survey invitation email where the subject lines were manipulated. Contrary to our initial prediction and expert forecasts, we found that impact appeals on average decreased feedback provision (compared to a straightforward control message). Importantly, impact appeals backfired to a greater extent in countries with lower trust in business (e.g., Japan) than in countries with higher trust in business (e.g., China). We theorize that impact appeals are more likely to reduce compliance among customers with lower trust in business because these customers perceive impact appeals as more inauthentic. Pre-registered lab experiments (N=7,926) support our theoretical account and test more effective impact appeals informed by it. This research sheds light on when and why highlighting impact can fail to motivate customers and even backfire, and more generally, it advances the field’s understanding of what drives customer engagement in empowering behaviors.
Mental Accounting for Consumer Stock Returns
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 22-016
David Dolifka, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Eitan Rude, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
2021
Do Different Forms of Prospection Lead to Different Emotional Outcomes?
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-001
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonTayler Bergstrom, PhD Student, Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Leveraging Past Adversity to Increase Prevention Behavior
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-002
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonIlana Brody, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Rationalization Reduction: Intervention Science to Promote Moral Action
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-003
Eugene Caruso, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonIlana Brody, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Noah J. Goldstein, Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
How People Perceive Invasiveness
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-004
Eugene Caruso, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonJon Bogard, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Megan Weber, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
The Impact of Policy Framing on Narratives for Poverty and Prosperity
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-005
Sherry Wu, Assistant Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonIlana Brody, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Megan Weber, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Three Essays on Norms
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-006
Noah J. Goldstein, Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Jon Bogard, Ph.D. Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Grocery Store Closures and Household Nutritional Choices
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-007
Sylvia Hristakeva, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonJulia Levine, Ph.D. Student, Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Is Money More Valued than Time in Cost Transparent Prices?
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-008
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonDavid Dolifka, Ph.D. Student, Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Neha Nair, Ph.D. Student, Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Consumer Spending in Response to Income or Balance Information
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-009
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonDavid Dolifka, Ph.D. Student, Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Stephanie Smith, Ph.D. Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Biased Prestige Inferences and How to Correct Them
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-010
Jana Gallus, Associate Professor of Strategy and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonGloria Danqiao Cheng, Ph.D. Student, Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Serena Does, Ph.D. Student, Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
The entrenchment effect: Why people persist with less-preferred behaviors
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-011
Alicea Lieberman, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
On Amir, Professor of Marketing, UC San Diego Rady School of Management
Ziv Carmon, Professor of Marketing, INSEAD
Understanding Fairness Perceptions in Demographic Segmentation and Targeting
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-012
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Elizabeth M.S. Friedman, Assistant Professor of Business, Columbia Business School
Olivier Toubia, Professor of Business, Columbia Business School
Understanding How Consumers Incorporate and Estimate Uncertainty
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-013
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonDavid Zimmerman, Ph.D. Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
The Impact of Dollar Store Expansion on Local Market Structure and Food Access
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-014
Brett Hollenbeck, Assistant Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
El Hadi Caoui, Assistant Professor of Strategic Management, University of Toronto
Matthew Osborne, Associate Professor of Marketing, Department of Management, University of Toronto
What Motivates Social Security Claiming Age Intentions? Testing Behaviorally-Informed Interventions Alongside Individual Differences
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-016
Adam Eric Greenberg, Assistant Professor of Marketing, Bocconi UniversityHal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Suzanne Shu, Professor Emeritus, UCLA Anderson
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Choosing when to claim Social Security Administration (SSA) benefits is a critical determinant of financial health during retirement. Complicating this important decision is the role of heterogeneity; each individual’s decision is affected by individual factors that limit the usefulness of standardized advice. While past work has examined heterogeneity in claiming decisions, there has been little research to systematically test the psychosocial correlates of early or delayed SSA claiming or the effectiveness of theory-driven interventions meant to help with the claiming decision. Given that prior research has typically tested one intervention or individual difference at a time, we systematically examined how several different interventions affect when consumers intend to claim SSA benefits and how such intentions correlate with individual differences. Using a pre-registered design with replications, we analyzed intended claiming age as a function of theory-driven interventions, individual difference measures, and relevant interactions between interventions and individual differences. In so doing, we not only generate better predictive models of which retirees will decide to claim earlier or later, but also provide a methodological roadmap for data-driven theory building for complex consumer decisions.
Recognition: Finalist for the 2023 Journal of Marketing Research Paul E. Green Award.
Modeling Consumer Choice Using Eye-Tracking
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 21-016
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonStephanie Smith, Ph.D. Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
2020
Back to the Present: How Direction of Mental Time Travel Affects Similarity and Saving
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-001
Kate Christensen, Assistant Professor in the Marketing, Kelly School of Business, Indiana University
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA Anderson
Urgency in Consumer Decision Making
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-002
Hal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Marketing Area Chair, UCLA AndersonJoseph Reiff, Assistant Professor of Marketing, Robert H. Smith School of Business at the University of Maryland
Many societal challenges facing consumers, such as mitigating climate change or increasing retirement savings, are said to require urgency. Yet, researchers have only just started exploring the construct of urgency and how it shapes judgments and decisions. What is urgency, why does it matter, and how can policy makers and marketers increase it? We plan to explore these questions in the current research program. Specifically, we define urgency as a preference for earlier action over later action. We plan to (1) develop a novel measure of urgency, showing that some people have a strong preference to act now, rather than later, even if that means forgoing significant amounts of money, (2) show that this preference negatively predicts consumer demand for certain behaviors that require delayed actions (e.g., borrowing, pre-commitment), and (3) show how to frame products to increase take-up by appealing to urgency.
Misperception about stigma as a potential barrier to applying for benefits programs
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-003
Sherry Wu, Assistant Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA AndersonEugene Caruso, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Alice Lee-Yoon, M & O Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Highlighting Opportunities (Versus Outcomes) Increases Support for Economic Redistribution
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-004
Franklin Shaddy, Assistant Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Kate Christensen, Assistant Professor in the Marketing, Kelly School of Business, Indiana University
David Dolifka, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Why Do Consumers Ignore Hidden Costs?
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-005
Jerry Nickelsburg, Faculty Director, UCLA Anderson Forecast, Adjunct Professor of Economics, UCLA AndersonLeila Bengali, Economist, UCLA Anderson Forecast
The Role of Place Attachment and Environmental Attitudes in Adoption of Rooftop Solar
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-006
Charles Corbett, Professor of Operations Management and Environmental Management, UCLA AndersonHal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson School of Management
Timothy Malloy, Professor of Law at UCLA School of Law
A recent paper in Nature Sustainability (Sunter et al. 2019) uses data from Google’s Project Sunroof to document that Black- and Hispanic-majority census tracts show significantly lower rates of solar PV installation, even after accounting for differences in household income and home ownership. As part of a project funded by the UCLA Sustainable Los Angeles (SLA) Grand Challenge, the current research team conducted a survey of 4,207 homeowners in Los Angeles County in April 2018. The survey focused on drivers of adoption of rooftop solar photovoltaic (PV). This project will focus on examining whether our survey responses shed new light on reasons for the disparities in adoption of rooftop solar documented by Sunter et al. (2019). For instance, we will explore to what extent these disparities also occur in LA County, and whether they are driven more by neighborhood-level, individual or other factors.
Consumer Financial Decision Making
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-008
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Associate Dean of Anderson Ph.D. Program, UCLA AndersonDavid Dolifka, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Kate Christensen, Assistant Professor in the Marketing, Kelly School of Business, Indiana University
Essays on the Uncertainty of Continuous Outcomes
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-009
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, Associate Dean of Anderson Ph.D. Program, UCLA Anderson
David Zimmerman, Behavioral Decision Making Ph.D. Student
Examining the role of COVID-19 testing availability on intention to isolate: A Randomized hypothetical scenario
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-009
Justin C. Zhang, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLAKate Christensen, Assistant Professor in the Marketing, Kelly School of Business, Indiana University
Richard K. Leuchter, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA
Sitaram Vangala, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA
Maria Han, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA
Daniel M. Croymans, David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA
Little information exists on how COVID-19 testing influences intentions to engage in risky behavior. Understanding the behavioral effects of diagnostic testing may highlight the role of adequate testing on controlling viral transmission. In order to evaluate these effects, simulated scenarios were conducted evaluating participant intentions to self-isolate based on COVID-19 diagnostic testing availability and results.
Beliefs that Entertain
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-010
Paola Giuliano, Professor of Economics, UCLA AndersonAshvin Gandhi, Assistant Professor of Economics, UCLA Anderson
The Market for Fake Reviews
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-011
Brett Hollenbeck, Associate Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Sherry He, Marketing Ph.D. Student, UCLA Anderson
Davide Prosperio, Assistant Professor of Marketing at the USC Marshall School of Business
Peer comparisons and choice architecture
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-012
Jon Bogard, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Effective altruism
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 20-013
Jon Bogard, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
2019
CEO Activism and Public Mobilization
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-002
Young Hou, Assistant Professor of Business Administration, Darden School of Business, University of VirginiaChristopher Poliquin, Assistant Professor of Strategy, UCLA Anderson
CEOs increasingly engage in activism on issues such as gun control, voting rights, and abortion. Although such activism may benefit their firms, the stated goal is often to mobilize the public and precipitate change. In an experiment with 4,578 respondents, we study the effect of CEO activism on people’s willingness to contact their U.S. senators about abortion. On average, showing a CEO message supporting abortion rights is not more effective at mobilizing pro-choice citizens than showing no message or showing a message from other speakers. Additionally, CEOs do not provoke countermobilization by people who oppose abortion. We explore heterogeneous treatment effects and find that CEO activism is better at motivating pro-choice citizens to engage in politics when their senators are Democrats and thus likely receptive to pro-choice activism, consistent with stakeholder alignment theory. Our findings contribute to research on social movements and mobilization in markets by examining the ability of CEOs and organizations to act as catalysts for social change.
The Role of Attention in Evaluating Choices Among Choices
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-003
Stephen Spiller, Associate Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA AndersonStephanie Smith, Ph.D. Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson School of Management
How do consumers value sets of alternatives and choose among them? The normative value of a set is derived from the expected value of the best option in the set. As a result, adding options to a set can increase the normative value but not decrease it. Yet prior work has found that the perceived value of a choice set systematically deviates from this normative benchmark: When less-attractive options are included in a set, the perceived value of the set decreases. In this research, we study how such undervaluation relates to visual attention by measuring what consumers attend to during choice. Prior research has found a causal role of attention in choices between liked items: The more attention an option receives, the more likely it is to be chosen. In this work, we examine how allocation of attention among options within a set relates to the ultimate choice of that set and implied perceived value. Through measuring visual attention, we hope to better understand how value is integrated across alternatives when one immediate choice opens the door to additional choices down the road.
Advertising Strategy in the Presence of Reviews: An Empirical Analysis
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-004
Brett Hollenbeck, Associate Professor of Marketing, UCLA AndersonSridhar Moorthy, Professor of Marketing at the Rotman School of Management, University of Toronto
Davide Proserpio, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Marketing, USC Marshall School of Business
We study the relationship between online reviews and advertising spending in the hotel industry. Combining a dataset of TripAdvisor reviews with other datasets describing these hotels’ advertising expenditures, we show, first, that online ratings have a causal demand-side effect on ad spending. Second, this effect is negative: Hotels with higher ratings spend less on advertising than hotels with lower ratings. This suggests that hotels treat TripAdvisor ratings and advertising spending as substitutes, not complements. Third, the relationship is stronger for independent hotels than for chains, and stronger in less differentiated markets than in more differentiated markets. The former suggests that a strong brand name continues to provide some immunity to reviews, and the latter suggests that the advertising response is stronger when ratings are more likely to be pivotal. Finally, we show that the relationship between online ratings and advertising has strengthened over time, just as TripAdvisor has become more popular, implying that firms respond to online reviews if and only if consumers respond to them.
Taxation and Market Power in the Legal Marijuana Industry
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-005
Brett Hollenbeck, Associate Professor of Marketing, UCLA Anderson
Kosuke Uetake, Associate Professor of Marketing, Yale School of Management
In 2012, the state of Washington created a legal framework for production and retail sales of marijuana. Ten other U.S. states and Canada have followed. These states hope to generate tax revenue for their state budgets while limiting harms associated with marijuana sales and consumption. We use a unique administrative dataset containing all transactions in the history of the industry in Washington to evaluate the effectiveness of different tax and regulatory policies under consideration by policymakers and study the role of imperfect competition in determining these results. We use both a reduced form sufficient statistic approach and structural methods to show a number of results. First, Washington’s strict cap on firm entry has resulted in retailers with substantial market power. This market power has immediate consequences for both state tax revenue and consumer welfare. Second, because these entry restrictions have caused retailers to behave like local monopolists, the state could substantially increase revenue generated from marijuana legalization by acting as the retailer itself, as it did for alcohol sales until 2012, without a large increase in prices. Third, despite having the nation’s highest tax rate at 37%, marijuana in Washington is not overtaxed, as many policymakers in other states have argued. The high taxes do not result in lower revenue or a substantial black market. Instead, Washington is still on the upward-sloping portion of the Laffer curve, and the amount of revenue generated by a tax increase is significantly larger due to retailer market power than it would be under perfect competition. Our results suggest there is not widely available black market marijuana competing with legal retail sales. Finally, the high excise tax is primarily borne by consumers and not by firms, and there is a large social cost associated with each dollar raised.
The Long-term and Spillover Effects of Price Promotions on Retailing Platforms: Evidence from a Large Randomized Experiment on Alibaba
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-006
Hengchen Dai, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Dennis J. Zhang, Olin Business School, Washington University in St. Louis
Lingxiu Dong, Olin Business School, Washington University in St. Louis
Fangfang Qi, Alibaba Group Inc.
Nannan Zhang, Alibaba Group Inc.
Xiaofei Liu, Alibaba Group Inc.
Zhongyi Liu, Alibaba Group Inc.
Jiang Yang, Alibaba Group Inc.
We study how promotions affect consumer behavior on an online retailing platform in the long term. We focus on a specific promotion: offering consumers coupons for products that have been in their shopping carts for more than one day. In a randomized field experiment involving more than 100 million customers with Alibaba Group—China’s largest e-commerce company—we randomly assigned half of eligible customers to a treatment condition where they might receive promotions for products in their shopping carts, while the other half of eligible customers did not receive coupons. We document unintended consequences of this promotion program during the month following our treatment period. On the positive side, our promotion program boosted consumer engagement, increasing the daily number of products customers viewed as well as customers’ daily purchase likelihood on the platform during the post-treatment period. On the negative side, we find that our promotion program intensified strategic consumer behaviors in two ways. First, receiving our promotions in the treatment period increased the proportion of products that consumers added to their shopping carts upon viewing them in the post-treatment period, possibly due to customers’ anticipation of promotions targeted at products in their shopping carts. Second, receiving our promotions in the treatment period lowered the prices customers paid for products in the post-treatment period. This effect holds for products that did not offer shopping-cart promotions, suggesting that prior use of shopping-cart promotions made people more price sensitive and trained them to search for other promotion mechanisms beyond shopping-cart-specific promotions. Importantly, both the positive and negative long-term effects spilled over to sellers on the same retailing platform that did not previously offer promotions to consumers. Our findings suggest that price promotions may change expectations and reference points, which can further produce both a positive long-term effect on consumer engagement and a negative long-term effect on strategic behavior. We discuss the practical implications of our findings for platforms and retailers.
The Value of Pop-up Stores in Driving Online Engagement in Platform Retailing: Evidence from a Large-Scale Field Experiment with Alibaba
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-007
Dennis J. Zhang, Olin Business School, Washington University in St. LouisHengchen Dai, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Lingxiu Dong, Olin Business School, Washington University in St. Louis
Qian Wu, Alibaba Group Inc.
Lifan Guo, Alibaba Group Inc.
Xiaofei Liu, Alibaba Group Inc.
We study the value of short-lived and experiential-oriented pop-up stores, a popular type of omnichannel retail strategy, on both retailers that participate in pop-up store events and retailing platforms that host these retailers. We conduct a large-scale, randomized field experiment with Alibaba Group involving approximately 800,000 customers. We randomly assign consumers to either receive a message about an upcoming weeklong pop-up store event organized by Alibaba’s business-to-consumer platform (Tmall.com) or not receive any message about the event. We find that our message increased foot traffic to the pop-up store and in turn boosted expenditure at participating retailers’ online stores at Tmall after the event ended. Furthermore, we use advanced Wi-Fi technology to track customers’ visits to the pop-up store—a missing component from past research that commonly relies on point-of-sales data. We find that pop-up store visits substantially increased customers’ subsequent expenditure at participating retailers’ Tmall stores. In addition, from a platform perspective, we show that pop-up store visits increased customers’ purchases at retailers that sell related products on Tmall but did not participate in the pop-up store event. Additional analyses shed light on possible mechanisms underlying the cross-channel and spillover effects of pop-up stores and demonstrate that these effects were concentrated on prospective consumers.
A Theory of Goal Maintenance: A Distinct and Vivid Pre-Goal Self Predicts Post-Goal Maintenance Motivation
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-007
Elicia Marie John, Doctor of Philosophy in Management, UCLA AndersonHal Hershfield, Professor of Marketing and Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson
Suzanne Shu, Professor Emeritus, UCLA Anderson
Prospective Retrospection
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-008
Eugene Caruso, Associate Professor of Management and Organizations, UCLA Anderson
Jon Bogard, PhD Student, Behavioral Decision Making, UCLA Anderson School of Management
The Role of Heritage Connection in Consumer Valuation
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-009
Suzanne Shu, Professor Emeritus, UCLA Anderson
Owners value heritage goods, items that connect them to a shared past, whether through their alma mater or their family history. This research considers the impact of heritage on owners who wish to sell such goods. In five studies, we demonstrate that sellers have a lower willingness-to-accept (WTA) for heritage goods when selling to buyers with a shared heritage connection relative to buyers without this connection (i.e., a heritage discount). This heritage discount cannot be explained by in-group favoritism, sentimental value, or appropriateness of buyer usage and persists even when sellers perceive that the buyer has a higher willingness-to-pay (WTP). We provide process evidence that the effect of the buyer’s identity on the seller’s WTA is driven by concerns about heritage loss. Our findings contribute to literatures on sharing, sentimental goods, psychological ownership, and the endowment effect, and have marketing implications for consumer goods (e.g., collectibles) that derive product value by connecting consumers to meaningful history and traditions.
Hypocrisy
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-010
Cassandra Davis, Assistant Professor in the Department of Public Policy, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Menu framing
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-011
Hannah Malan, PhD in Community Health Sciences, UCLA Anderson
VIP Effect in Service Settings
Morrison Center Working Paper No. 19-012
Alexandra Polyakova, Assistant Professor of Marketing at Toulouse Business School