Open For Good Methodology

Our Methodology
![]()
The Open For Good research analysis draws on a comprehensive sample of firms listed in the S&P 500 during the study period. Once a company enters the index, it remains in the dataset for all subsequent years analyzed, even if it was included for only a single year. Consequently, the denominator reflects every single firm that has been in the S&P 500 during the sample window, minimizing the influence of index turnover on the reported trends. Companies that were listed in the S&P 500 between Q1 2020 and Q4 2024 are included, and companies that are no longer publicly listed as of Q4 2024 are removed.
For our 2023, 2024 and 2025 reports, we collected data on metrics spanning Environmental, Social and Governance topics (Delmas et al., 2023; Delmas et al., 2024; Delmas et al., 2025). These metrics were derived from the World Economic Forum’s (WEF) Stakeholder Capitalism Metrics, as it comprises an array of the most widely agreed-upon metrics. We further modified some of its underlying components based on the results of our earlier research, which the 2023 report has outlined (Delmas et al., 2023).
For our 2026 report, we continued collecting the adapted WEF metrics in addition to expanding to metrics for climate risk assessment and transition planning. With several organizations offering guidance for transition plans and no clear gold standard, a framework analysis was completed to achieve an understanding of the most broadly agreed-upon metrics. Forty-one metrics emerged across 26 voluntary disclosure frameworks, regulations and guidance documents.
Quantitative metrics (e.g., GHG emissions, net-zero target years) were taken directly from public documents and filings. For each qualitative metric, companies received a score of “0” if they did not disclose responsive information or “1” if they fully disclosed the relevant information. Board competency data was retrieved using ChatGPT-5 mini, which scanned 2025 proxy statements for educational or professional experience related to environmental issues. These issues included climate, renewable energy, ESG, environmental policy and sustainable innovation. Climate-related metrics, such as climate risks and emissions, were retrieved from the companies’ public ESG or sustainability reports in 2024, following the same methodology. Following the preliminary extraction, the results were quality-checked by individual research assistants, who compared them with the original reports. Those quality checks were then reviewed by a second member of the research team. Following data collection, we ensured precision by cross-verifying each entry with a second team member. The team examined and rectified any identified inconsistencies. We also conducted outlier checks for each metric to further confirm their accuracy.
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose its Scope 1 emissions?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose its market-based Scope 2 emissions?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose its location-based Scope 2 emissions?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 2 emissions without specifying whether they are market based or location based?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose its Scope 3 emissions?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 1 emissions (purchased goods and services)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 2 emissions (capital goods)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 3 emissions (energy)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 4 emissions (upstream transport)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 5 emissions (waste)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 6 emissions (business travel)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 7 emissions (employee commuting)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 8 emissions (upstream leased assets)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 9 emissions (downstream transportation)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 10 emissions (processing of sold products)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 11 emissions (use of sold products)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 12 emissions (end of life of sold products)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 13 emissions (downstream leased assets)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 14 emissions (franchises)?
GHG emissions: Does the company disclose Scope 3, Category 15 emissions (investments)?
Targets: Does the company have a net-zero target?
Targets: What year does the company aim to achieve net zero?
Climate-related risks: Does the company discuss climate-related physical risks?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify flooding as a physical climate risk?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify extreme heat as a physical climate risk?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify wildfire as a physical climate risk?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify drought as a physical climate risk?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify sea level rise as a physical climate risk?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify hurricanes as a physical climate risk?
Climate-related risks: Does the company identify tornadoes as a physical climate risk?
Audit assurance: Does the company obtain external assurance on its sustainability report?
Audit assurance: Which assurance provider verifies the sustainability report?
Audit assurance: Which parts of the sustainability report are covered by assurance?
Director governance: What is the director's name?
Director governance: Does the company identify the director as having environmental expertise?
Director governance: Is executive compensation linked to sustainability metrics or targets?
Targets: Is executive and/or non-executive compensation linked to sustainability metrics or targets?
Transition planning: Does the company discuss its climate transition plan?
I want to learn more about:
