Mgmt 298D-3
Competition, Markets, and Power
Spring Quarter 2000
| Instructor: | Sushil Bikhchandani |
| Class Time: | Tuesdays, 6:00-8:50pm |
| Class Room: | B313, Gold Hall |
| Office Hours: | Before class in room D516 or by appointment |
| Tel: (310) 206-2686 | |
| Fax: (310) 825-1581 | |
| E-mail: sbikhcha@anderson.ucla.edu | |
| Materials: | Readings packet |
| Book: | Co-opetition by Adam Brandenburger and Barry Nalebuff, Doubleday Press, 1996. |
Course Description
This course provides a conceptual framework for thinking strategically about business decisions. Interactions between the firm and parties external to it are examined through the lens of game theory. Business is viewed as a dead serious game played between a firm, its customers, its suppliers, its substitutors, and its complementors. There are two dimensions of interaction in this game. Along the vertical dimension are the firm’s customers and suppliers – players with whom the firm transacts. Along the horizontal dimension are its substitutors and complementors – players (other firms) with which the firm interacts but does not usually transact. A firm’s share of the value created by players in a game of business depends on the players’ added values, the rules of interaction, the tactics employed, and the exploitation of links to other games.
The framework is based on ideas underlying game theory, ideas such as recognizing interdependencies among players, getting away from the win-lose mindset, the importance of added value of a player, anticipating other players’ reactions to one’s own actions. A large number of cases and other applications, including several from the information technology sector, demonstrate the usefulness of this framework in thinking about how to change the game to one’s advantage.
Course Work
Although the emphasis in this course is conceptual rather than quantitative, number-crunching is required for gleaning qualitative insights from many of the cases. Classes will be a mixture of lectures and case discussions. You should read the case(s) and other reading materials assigned for each class and be prepared to discuss them. You will be asked to submit three or four written case analysis as homework.
The following written home assignments will be graded:
| 1. | A Value Net Exercise | Due at the beginning of class 2, April 11 |
| 2. |
Harnfischeger Industries: |
Due at the beginning of class 3, April 18 |
| 3. | Judo Economics | Due at the beginning of class 5, May 2 |
| 4. | Changing the Game Exercise | Due at the beginning of class 10, June 6 |
Note: the first three assignments are worth 4% each. Assignment 4 carries a weight of 8%.
Grades will be based on:
Class Participation 30%
Written Case Analyses 20%
Final Examination 50%
Class Outline (cases are in italics)
Class 1: April 4
Course Introduction
Mindset, Map, and Method of Changing the Game
Mindset: "Coopetition"
Map: "Value Net"
Method: "PARTS"
Read chapters 1 & 2, Brandenburger and Nalebuff (BN)
"Its Only a Game," The Economist, June 15, 1996.
"Making Game Theory Work in Practice," WSJ, Feb. 20, 1995.
Class 2: April 11
H.A. 1: Submit "A Value Net Exercise"
Module A: Added Values
Definition of Value
The Added Value Principle
Read "Value-based Business Strategy" by Brandenburger
and Stuart
chapters 3 & 5, BN
Value Analysis (A): A Card Game
Value Analysis (B): A Bankruptcy Problem from the Talmud
Class 3: April 18
H.A. 2: Submit Harnfischeger Industries: An added value exercise
Intel Corporation: 1968-1997
Power Play (A): Nintendo in 8-bit Video Games
Changing Added Values
Read chapter 5, BN
Class 4: April 25
Module B: Players
"Brand-name B-Schools: Partnering with Start-ups for Revenue and
Reach"
AACSB: The International Association of Management Education
New Blood in a Dying Business
Changing the Players
Read chapter 4, BN
Class 5: May 2
Module C: Rules
H.A. 2: Submit Analysis of Judo Economics
ViewSonic Corpn.
"The Season of Upstart Startups" Business Week, Aug. 31, 1992.
The Free-rider Problem: Airline Frequent-flyer Programs
The Toy Game
Read chapter 6, BN
Class 6: May 9
General Motors Leads the Charge: The Launch of the GM Card
"GM to Offer 'Loyalty' Coupons to Existing Owners," WSJ, Jan. 5, 2000
Changing the Rules
Read chapter 6, BN
Class 7: May 16
Module D: Tactics: The Game Theory of Asymmetric Information
Asymmetric Information: Market Failures, Market Distortions, and Market Solutions
Signalling Costs
Informational Cascades and Herd Behavior
Class 8: May 23
Auctions and the Winner’s Curse
"Going, Going, Gone...Sucker! Business Week, Mar. 20, 2000
Using Tactics to Change Perceptions
Read chapter 7, BN
Class 9: May 30
Module E: Scope
Bundling
"Strategy and the New Economics of Information," by Evans and Wurster
Changing the Scope
Read chapter 8, BN
Class 10: June 6
H.A. 4: Submit "Changing the Game Exercise"
Network Externalities and Standards
Formatting the Disc: The High Density Video Standard Battle
The Browser Wars, 1994-1998
Course wrap-up
Read chapter 9, BN
June 13: Final exam