Mgmt. 298D – Electronic Commerce
Fall 1998
Prof. A. Geoffrion
A Review of Webonomics: Nine Essential Principles
for Growing Your Business on the World Wide Web, by Evan Schwartz,
Broadway Books, 1997
Written for Classroom Use Only
© Arthur M. Geoffrion
September, 1998
This well-regarded and influential book was the 24th overall best-selling
book for Amazon.com for 1997, and for a time was its #1 best-selling business
book. The Amazon.com page for this book, namely http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ISBN%3D0553061720/cyberpos1998neteA/002-9704725-5638825,
contains comments -- nearly all gushing, uninformative praise from "friendlies"
-- and no fewer than 49 readers to date.
Evan Schwartz’s qualifications are a B.S. in Computer Science, experience
writing for Business Week, Wired, The New York Times,
and other outlets, a lively intuition, strong opinions, and good writing
skills. The book is an expansion, written by popular demand, of his very
popular article "Advertising Webonomics 101" in Wired, February
1996.
I considered making this one of your texts, but decided that it lacked
the breadth and depth you needed for a serious course. For example, it
is heavily preoccupied with marketing and consists mainly of the author’s
personal opinions. However, you can read this book to good advantage now
that you possess the requisite foundations. And it is a hugely fun
book to read, with engaging material on almost every page.
The book consists of an introduction, a chapter on each of the nine
"principles" (each with a nice summary at the end), a forgettable Epilogue,
extensive endnotes, a nice appendix that collects all of the Web sites
mentioned in the text into 29 categories, and a pretty good index.
The introductory chapter, which is available free in its entirety at
http://www.businessweek.com/chapter/evanchap.htm,
gives some essential background on the Web. Schwartz emphasizes that the
Web’s economy is determined by the battle to command and sustain the attention
of busy people. In particular, he believes in the importance of forging
lasting relationships with consumers.
Below are the nine chapter titles, which are identical to the nine principles
mentioned in the book’s subtitle, together with what I consider to be the
main "meat" in each. In some cases, I offer my own comments. The principles
are billed as "timeless strategies for conducting commerce on the World
Wide Web." Underlining indicates hyperlinks that are active in the Web
version of this document.
1. The Quantity of People Visiting Your Site is Less Important Than
the Quality of Their Experience
-
Schwartz contrasts the Playboy site,
which has lots of visitors but amounts to an unabashed advertisement for
the printed magazine, and Bianca’s
Smut Shack, which provides a far higher quality experience to visitors
and hence ought to be more successful over the long term. The Shack is
the third most popular adult-oriented site after the Playboy and Penthouse,
which speaks very well for its design considering the enormous advantages
of its competition in terms of established brand. The main reason: the
Shack provides a sense of community that the other sites don’t.
-
"The name of the game for any content creator on the Web is to find a unique
niche, then use the interactive features of the Web to cater to a very
specific and loyal group of individuals. The actual size of the audience
should be a secondary consideration." This advice is in perfect harmony
with Tim O’Reilly’s view (week 5 reading), who adds that the Web may be
gigantic, but only because it is the summation of lots and lots of niches.
-
Schwartz richly praises the San Jose
Mercury News (slated for class discussion) for its interactive delivery
of a quality experience to users.
-
Schwartz make the interesting comment that, when put on the Web, magazines
and newspapers literally "deconstruct," that is, they break up into their
constituent elements: "Instead of flipping through pages in a linear fashion,
readers may pick and choose from menus of stories, look up stock quotes,
search databases of classified ads, and have conversations with editors
and other readers." The smart publications realize that the Web is a far
richer and more interactive medium than print, are busy exploiting the
new opportunities, and using their print editions to promote their Web
sites. Business Week and the
Wall Street Journal are cited as good
examples. The right goal for on-line publications, he claims, is not to
boost market share, but to boost "mindshare" among the most important customers
-- that is, to boost the amount of time that such people spend interacting
with a Web site’s brand name.
-
Schwartz offers an extended appreciation of ESPN
SportsZone as a site that not only attracts very large numbers of people,
but also delivers a high-quality, interactive experience to a core group
of consumers. Of course, he attributes the former to the latter. That is
a path to financial success since advertisers will pay for access to such
markets. For sites that choose not to adopt the Advertising Model (as we
call it), "the invention of new value-added services offers the best path
to profitability." For news and information sites, this includes "specialized
delivery of knowledge, advice, or wisdom."
-
In summary, Schwartz stresses that long-term success comes when a Web site
offers something of unique value that causes people to return repeatedly;
that it is important to build an "online community where people with similar
interests want to congregate and interact"; that the Web is an inherently
interactive, niche, and ultimately personal medium; and that on-line publications
should focus on reinventing their paper publications to create "a participatory
experience that builds on the relationship the overall brand has with its
readers."
2. Marketers Shouldn't Be on the Web for Exposure, But for Results
-
This chapter is mainly about advertising. Schwartz doesn’t believe that
the Web is very effective for burnishing a brand image with the masses;
he believes that TV and print are much better for that. Just turning advertising
brochures into Web sites is a formula for failure, for the Web is inherently
a pull medium rather than a push one. Instead, Web ads should
learn (interactively) about viewers’ preferences, provide service, and
link to in-depth product information.
-
The Prudential Securities Web site
is cited as an example of service-based marketing. It was one of the first
financial sites "in which existing customers could instantly look up their
account balances, perform transactions on their portfolio, and send E-mail
to their personal financial advisor -- and expect an answer." Don’t shout
your message repeatedly in the faces of viewers as in mass marketing, Schwartz
says, but identify and respond to viewers’ needs.
-
Schwartz believes that most Web advertising should be reserved for sites
that attract well qualified and interested consumers inclined toward visiting
regularly, rather than be wasted on sites with more but less loyal visitors.
-
Schwartz believes that the total dominance of mass-media advertising is
diminishing for four reasons he calls "the Four Cs: clutter (too
many ads coming at us), clicking (the ability to channel surf during
commercials), cynicism (people no longer believe what the ads say),
and competition (first from direct marketing and now from interactive
media)."
-
Schwartz asserts that there are four main ways to promote a marketing Web
site: "by mentioning the address in print and TV ads, by garnering press
attention, by trading ‘hyperlinks’ with other Web sites -- thus building
‘electronic word-of-mouth,’ and finally by purchasing banner placements
of popular content sites."
3. Consumers Must Be Compensated for Disclosing Data About Themselves
-
The more you know about a Web site’s viewers the better you will be able
to serve them. But how to obtain information about viewers who, for the
most part, don’t want to be bothered or who have privacy concerns? Something
must be given in return for "registering" or answering some (demographic
or psychographic) questions. That something could be a discount on products,
access to non-free content, a service such as advice from a recommendation
system on something of interest, or access to an on-line community.
-
Schwartz recommends that Web sites take advantage of the information they
collect about viewers to provide some tangible benefit that would not be
possible without that information.
-
Schwartz points out that collected information often has considerable commercial
value, and believes that visitors ought to be told in advance whether it
will be sold.
-
Some specific sites discussed include Hotwired
(launched in 1994, it was one of the first sites to grapple with how to
compensate viewers for the data they were asked to disclose), Firefly
(reportedly making 1/3 of its revenue from selling information on its’
members tastes, 1/3 from advertising, and 1/3 from licensing its proprietary
software and agent technology), and Stolichnaya
vodka (whose site offers each visitor the chance to design their own vodka-based
drink and have it listed publicly along with their name).
4. Consumers Will Shop Online Only for Information-Rich Products
-
Notice that Schwartz did not say "digital products", but rather "information-rich
products." Any product qualifies so long as there are sufficient opportunities
to dispense facts, news, knowledge, wisdom, or advice about it.
-
Schwartz points out that most cybermalls have failed or are failing because
they are imitations of the real-life mall, which is based on the notions
of good (and hence scarce) geographical location and the advantage of physical
proximity as a lure to one-stop shoppers. But these notions lose much of
their force on the Web owing to its inherent nature (e.g., geography is
moot and browsers can switch to any other store as easily as they
can switch to another store in the same cybermall).
-
This chapter discusses Virtual Vineyards
and Amazon.com at length as examples
of sites that fully exploit the information-richness of their products.
-
The chapter also discusses some successful sites that don’t seem to fit
the title especially well, including: NetMarket,
which makes nearly all its revenue by selling memberships to consumers
who want to buy a vast array of merchandise directly from manufacturers;
JCPenney, which has an on-line bridal
registry and an aggressive program to use its rich customer account database
on about 100 million customers to create a more personalized on-line shopping
experience; and Peapod, a personalized
grocery shopping service.
5. Self-Service Provides for the Highest Level of Customer Comfort
-
Schwartz thinks self-service Web sites are popular because they offer convenience,
give a feeling of control, and preclude most of the kinds of mistakes that
clerks often make.
-
Some of the sites featured in this chapter are: Federal
Express, which offers a hugely successful on-line package tracking
service; the U.S. Postal Service site,
which offers a wide array of on-line services; Wells
Fargo, the first bank to fully embrace banking on the Web; and the
Internal Revenue Service, which
runs one of the most popular government sites that is enabling it to cut
thousands of customer service workers.
-
There is extensive discussion of the Web’s impact on the travel industry.
-
Schwartz points out that self-service is becoming mandatory in many industries
as a competitive requirement. The Web is often an excellent medium in which
to achieve it.
6. "Value-Based Currencies" Enable You to Create Your Own Monetary System
-
Schwartz believes that there is a great future for corporate "value-based
currencies" redeemable for real goods and services. An early example was
frequent flyer miles, but by now many other industries have done something
similar in an attempt to build customer loyalty. [According to the CEO
of Hollywood Stock Exchange, who spoke
at the spring 1998 offering of this course, their Hollywood Dollars will
soon be convertible into frequent flyer miles, which amounts to making
Hollywood Dollars a value-based currency.] Schwartz offers some original
ideas of his own on how various specific companies could introduce value-based
currencies.
-
The Web is the perfect medium for people to manage their various value-based
currency accounts; they will visit each one regularly to check their balance
and find out what they can buy with their points. Note that this offers
the sponsoring company a nice repeating opportunity to interact with its
customers.
-
Schwartz believes that the companies which will enjoy the greatest success
with value-based currencies will be those that establish the strongest
sense of trust with their consumers (because these "currencies" can expire
or be revalued at the whim of their issuer).
-
This chapter deals with most proposed electronic payment systems. Schwartz
points out that most digital cash and micropayment schemes are not catching
on very well. He believes that they just add an extra unneeded layer of
complexity and cost, and are annoying to most people when so much of what
is on the Web is free. Besides, most consumers lack the patience to mess
with what are essentially new kinds of credit and debit cards when their
existing cards can be used securely over the Web. Consumers are gradually
becoming more comfortable using their cards over the Web, and this spells
trouble for many electronic payment systems. Another source of trouble
for digital cash schemes that preserve anonymity is merchant resistance;
it is not in their best interests to adopt a payment medium that makes
it difficult for them to establish a relationship with their customers.
7. Trusted Brand Names Matter Even More on the Web
-
Schwartz argues that brand names matter even more on the Web than in real
life because Webspace is coming to be even more crowded and cluttered than
real space. Besides, the opportunities for fraud are even greater on the
Web, where you can’t meet a merchant face to face and judge trustworthiness
by the myriad of clues available in real life.
-
Establishing a new brand name on the Web may be very difficult unless you
are the first to do something. In any case, it is common to begin
by giving your product or service away, and then exploit your new brand
to generate revenue on related products or services. But don’t depend totally
on advertising revenue, says Schwartz, because you’ll likely have to plow
a good deal of that back into advertising your site so that you can maintain
your appeal to advertisers.
-
Schwartz points out that the power of brand names is so great that some
companies are trading on their good names to sell products and services
on the Web that have nothing to do with their main business. As examples,
he gives Microsoft Expedia (travel
agency), IBM’s World Avenue (cybermall), Intuit
(life insurance), and AOL (advertising agency). IBM’s cybermall folded
since the book was published.
8. Even the Smallest Business Can Compete in the Web's Global "Marketspace"
-
Schwartz says that the most dramatic advantage of doing business on the
Web is global reach, especially for purely digital products and services.
He offers quite a few dramatic examples. He also chides U.S. Webmasters
for failing to support languages other than English in most cases. He gives
the status of Internet penetration in other countries, and points out the
inevitable growth of same, thereby giving access to huge markets that are
all but virgin to most U.S. companies.
-
There is an extensive discussion of Internet telephony, which of course
is particularly cost-advantageous for international calls.
-
I should point out that some other authorities question this principle.
They point out that established companies with deep pockets can sometimes
crush upstart Web competitors using a variety of competitive strategies
and tactics.
9. Agility Rules--Web Sites Must Constantly Adapt to the Market
-
Schwartz offers Federal Express, Microsoft,
and PointCast as good examples
of how to adapt Web strategy to current events, which unfold with startling
speed on the Web. Similar agility will be important for most companies
doing business on the Web, he believes.
-
He recommends that new Web services be tested on loyal customers before
formal introduction.
In summary, the nine principles are fairly easy to accept, even obvious
in most cases, and are fleshed out in a useful way that makes reading this
book worthwhile. However, these principles are based largely on personal
opinion rather than "research".
Schwartz has created a Web site at www.webonomics.com
that promotes his brand (himself) to past and future readers. This site
contains information on himself, on the book, links to on-line versions
of most articles he has written during the last few years (some of them
of considerable interest), a cute 18-yes-no question webonomics questionnaire
for Web site owners that will be graded automatically, a free quarterly
newsletter, and more. The newsletter is worth browsing, since it comments
often on current developments that relate to one or another of his principles.
In it you will learn such things as:
-
According to the 7 July 1997 issue of Barron’s, "not a single case
of credit-card theft on the Net has been documented."
-
AT&T has moved its TrueRewards program to the Net, creating a new example
of what Schwartz calls "value-based currency". Another such example is
AutoByTel’s new Mobalist program (redeemable for dollars off on a new car).
-
Virtual Vineyards is getting only one or two CyberCash orders per week.
-
AutoByTel is now facilitating about $1/2 billion worth of new car sales
per month.
-
Affiliate networks (think of Amazon’s program) "have been cropping up at
a breath-taking rate, in almost every conceivable product category".